Wilian+vs.+Dett+-+Jacob+Boucher

Comments 6/25/13, Debate Dett vs Willian AFF: Willian -1ac try breathing more naturally, and don’t strain towards the end of your reading -slow down when transitioning from tag or card, good that you say and in-between card transitions, however try switching it up from time to time, debate still has aspects of good speaking in it still -status of the kritik, in the cross x - same to the 2a as the 1 n sow down on more wordy things like the condo flow -put the case first in every speech except if they read t -don’t need ev to prve VTL, just that if thre was such thing as VTL we need life -neeed more time on the case flow

Neg: Dett -press them on more links instead of asking them what the aff does, and try not wasting so much time on 1 link, if it takes the entire c-x. K links are easy to assert than others, because there answers will be the same if you c-x question press is the card -1n slow down when transitioning from card to card, you are very fast and clear however k tags are ridiculously long and need time to help me understand better, I know the cap k but id like to here more from you and not from what I know of it, you had a lot of time in the end, use that time to slow down and help me understand more -even if he cant cite the source the evidence is there, just a reason why the aff should be skeptical not thrown away - learn to flash you debate paperless its something you will have to deal with -dropped a impact turn on the apsment DA, easy out for the AFF (Easy answer would be the new world of cap no longer requires embargo on the econ structure)

Decisions: Voted AFF No impacts to the cap K, when the AFF wins the sustaibable argument, at worst the state will be vlnt and oppress them. Need more case coverage in the end, but I still grant you access the the extinction impact. Neg undercovers the case debate in the 2NR, and im not sure what the impact to the K does to me, I become money? So what, I enjoy this system, prove how the system dehumanizes ppl, like the abuse that occurs overseas yo foreign workers

2NC cap

Cap conditions are less in the new limits, cban are ignored by vast capitalist system and the failure I s going to be good for someone. Cuban is the only cou try that hasn’t given into the imprlism us econ engament is a rcss fo caplitlst econ, cap comdinzed the world and the alt is try or die cap is the root cause of bidrgtion and mass death/genocide, the perm cant solve for multi world changes with the use implsm. The fall of cap is invetiable. Neolbrl cao is at crisis point now. LA restnt is key to the alt angst neolbrlsm

Appsment Can have threat of nuclear war, cant tell countries what to do Frther appsmnt incrase bldshd Aff only excuses trnnny

LA rltns is k2 prvnt new cold war, and the AFF only increases prescne and makes the power war

1NR CAP Cant perm the alt, it is try or do, if we don’t transition the world will end, cant over come the world if the enemies aren’t even real, enviro dsction and NW have no dth count, just need to prove what is more imprtnt allows gov to explit more ad more ppl, makes the cllpse even work when you have to deal with the impct to eh K, voting neg helps you learn more about the world and to appcte what it means to not explt other invidvls Ldrshp This is the link to the K, because it is the neolbrl American aggnda and it assumes that ever other country is bad is is going to ry to kill everyone, and everyone dies in the world of the cllpse Wnt be any bigger because the cllpse isn’t as bad

Inhrncy Hmn rights isn’t a reason why we should do something, and we get better pay off by going post cllpse

1AR CAP: Rfse to descrb how and why the econ systm gets worse, no wrrnt ot the no VTL argment, cncded in the Conceded tat the Gbsn Grhm evdnce that cap bad is a totalizing vw that cant change the systm and no chnge actlly happns cant eval any of them, no wrrnts the the card thatle, say cap isn’t sustanabe, no impact to the k, k impacts is a net lose

china DA that they have no link to chna and the US prsnce

APsment The embargo increases the regime

Case Conceded the slvncy that econ is k2 solve war and hm rights Rltns and rdhsip k2 solve Ex

2NR China Can compte with china

Apsmnt Tst of comp ( WRONG)

Cap They are neolbrl cap, extend that some parts of cap that can change, but it needs to fall down, and admit that it needs to go. Cap comdizes all existence and comfidfies everything and given a value, ppl in china are worth less, causes the holocaust and hirshma and other captlist impacts, vote neg because the aff plan is too capitllst, voting aff gives me a number and dehumanizes everyone and leads to impacts

Case

2AR CAP Concsns in the last speech, the berry evdnc isn’t btter because it is only 1 yr newer, cap is sustainable because cap has sruvvied this long even when people say the cap is going to cllpse and that the impact isn’t going to happen, vlnt rpssion that occrs from the state leads to a worse impact by the government and cap state, they conceded the G.G. evidence and prohits the actual policies made by the states, sayin it’s the root cause of war vlnce and genocide is a reason why the alt wont be good because it wont lead to anything better. Both argments suck, and the perm sucks sure

Case Conceded that econ leadership is good for econ and when we gain trade from cuba it leads to soft power and hedge prevents extinctions, and this scenario outweighs, they don’t win the barry evidence, the alt doesn’t do anything to change it, no warrants from barry